Summer transfer rumours.

G

GJP

Well-Known Member
But you look at someone like Mark Noble who never gets a cap, but he's a quality player and definite Premier League quality

Meanwhile Nicky Butt retires with 39 :confused:

Nicky Butt also has numerous Premier League medals. FA and League Cups etc. Plus a Champions League. To add to all those England caps.

Which he has because he was a very good player.

And a better one than Mark Noble.
 
Canaryboy

Canaryboy

Well-Known Member
There is a ridiculous big club bias with England though. Did you notice how Nicky Butt's England career finished the moment he moved to Newcastle at 28? Did he become a worse player overnight?

I actually think that Mark Noble is a very good player and one of the best of his generation not to get an England cap, and its due to his loyalty as a one club man to West Ham. Fair play to him for not selling his soul and moving to a big 5 club at the first opportunity to help fill a homegrown player quota like wasteman Jack Rodwell (England International, by the way).

Although Butt vs Noble comparison isn't a great one, because there is a decade between them. How about we just point out that Jack Rodwell has 3 England caps because he sat on the bench for Man City occasionally and won a Premier League medal with 11 appearances one season, and Mark Noble has 0 to show for 14 years at West Ham (many of them as their captain) and 12 years in the Premier League? He used to captain the England U21's by the way.

If he'd gone and sat on the bench at Chelsea for a year early in his career like Scott Parker he'd have a higher profile for the rest of his days and been seen as more fashionable and therefore worthy of England selection.... Parker was bang average too, and won nothing, but got 18 caps because he was a backup player at a couple of big clubs.

ps. Plenty of very mediocre players have been involved in successful teams and picked up medals, and many class players finish having won very little. By your criteria David May was better than Tony Adams?
 
Last edited:
Canaryboy

Canaryboy

Well-Known Member
People were talking about Howson for England once.... Noble is a better player.
 
Last edited:
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
People were talking about Howson for England once.... Noble is a better player.
I don't remember anyone talking about Howson for England, other than biased Norwich fans lol! Would have loved it, mind.
 
G

GJP

Well-Known Member
Clearly there are a few sh*tty decisions when it comes to England call ups.

Noble is a very good player but not a great one. Not that all England players are great but I don't tend to watch anyone in midfield for England and think he would be better.

They could do with someone more dynamic in the middle and that should be Shelvey.
 
Canaryboy

Canaryboy

Well-Known Member
Shelvey gained a bit of a reputation as a liability last season and earlier in this season unfortunately, probably scared Southgate off of picking him for a major tournament.

Shame Wilshere got injured again in March really, was starting to show what he was capable of again for the first time in a long time. Absence of guile in midfield is probably why Southgate's tactics so often bypass that part of the pitch, was a bit shocked how direct we were. Did look quite effective in the first half though, albeit against Tunisia.... see how that goes against Belgium :D

Morty I think it was Howson who said that he wanted to get into the England squad when he arrived, so did Hooper. Both probably getting a little bit ahead of themselves.

Grant Holt was gutted not to get the call in 2012. Was never going to get one was he, although Kevin Davies got one or two so stranger things have happened!
 
Canaryboy

Canaryboy

Well-Known Member
Do think it was a bit of travesty that Hucks didn't get a few really, especially as we kept hearing about how England didn't have any left wingers when he was playing... sure they could have given him a go against Azerbaijan or something to see how he got on! Think Michael Gray got a few on that left side, he's probably the Norwich player who could be most aggrieved (since Ian Crook).
 
hogesar

hogesar

Well-Known Member
Whether he'll fit into the England squad or not is a different question, looking at how they played tonight and he doesn't fit into that at all.... forgot how ugly our style of football is, we don't really do patient passing football and advanced playmakers do we :D

Maddison will probably retire wishing that he was born half Dutch or Portuguese.

Eh? We played Sterling, Lingard and Alli in our starting 11. We dominated possession and passed the ball around (Tunisia passed the ball around too, to be fair).

Not sure how you determine we don't do patient passing football as that's what most people were moaning at us for in the second half!
 
Canaryboy

Canaryboy

Well-Known Member
Oh OK I'm so sorry, Iniesta wouldn't get anywhere near our side and a genius new possession based tactic which combines the best bits from Tika-Taka and Total Football with some proprietary ideas from footballing legend Gareth Southgate will undoubtedly take us all the way to the final. I'm easy. However you like it to be cooked.
 
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
Screenshot_20180620-153244_Twitter.jpg
 
Fenway Frank

Fenway Frank

Well-Known Member
Jaiyesimi to Yeovil on season long loan, spent last season at Grimsby
 
G

GJP

Well-Known Member
Yeah, Leitner and Marshall.

Still be looking for a keeper and a striker.

So another 4 players minimum...
 
Canaryboy

Canaryboy

Well-Known Member
Good move for Maddison I think. Hopefully we've got a little bit of cash to spend now? A known striker in early would settle everybody down a bit.

No 'thanks to Norwich' tweet yet though? Gone straight in with the 'dream move' tweet. Usual etiquette is to do the gushing oscars style thanks list, mentioning the fans at least twice, and then to post the new press photos :p
 
Din

Din

Well-Known Member
No 'thanks to Norwich' tweet yet though? Gone straight in with the 'dream move' tweet. Usual etiquette is to do the gushing oscars style thanks list, mentioning the fans at least twice, and then to post the new press photos :p

Have to admit I thought that :D I imagine though we'll see it tomorrow.
 
Din

Din

Well-Known Member
Think it's the perfect move for Maddison. Can't wait to see what he'll do in the Prem, undoubtedly a future England regular.

£22m rising to £25m is great business as well. Now let's go and get some players in ourselves, starting with Leitner. Him, Jack Marriott, Marcus Maddison, and Danny Ward and Eddie Nketiah on loan would be perfect IMO. Leistner on a free in place of Klose maybe as well. So hopefully someone with the power to make signings is reading this, because I clearly speak a lot of sense.
 
N

Number 9

Well-Known Member
Good move for Maddison I think. Hopefully we've got a little bit of cash to spend now? A known striker in early would settle everybody down a bit.

No 'thanks to Norwich' tweet yet though? Gone straight in with the 'dream move' tweet. Usual etiquette is to do the gushing oscars style thanks list, mentioning the fans at least twice, and then to post the new press photos :p
Has he not done that already? I seem to recall him thanking everyone and all but saying goodbye at the end of the season.
 

Sit with the City fans who turn up

Free to join, free to read. Introduce yourself, pick a player thread, and get stuck into the next match thread.

Create a free account
Top