Stadium improvements.

morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member

What needs improving? And how much do you think the club should consult with fans, because whatever they do, someone won't be happy with it!

A lot of the stadium facilities are looking a bit dated now. I used to sit in the Upper Barclay many moons ago and half time was ridiculous, it was a straight choice between a queue for the toilet, or a queue for a beer! I sit in the City stand sometimes for cup games and the facilities there are pretty poor too. Especially if you compare to the Jarrold, and the Lion and Castle in the lower Barclay.

Also, I feel a bit for the ladies, because it seems when they designed the whole stadium, somebody decided that ladies do not go to football, so lets not bother putting many toilets in!
 
D

DraytonBoy

New Member
I'm in the City Stand and have a brilliant seat right by the tunnel, wouldn't want to swap but the facilities are appalling.
 
B

Bill and ben

Member
Its not a question of should something be done, but how much. Unfortunately though we are a club with fans that seem to think that they entitled to the same seat for life -and beyond - so any change, no matter how small, is always going to cause massive upset.
 
AyrshireBob

AyrshireBob

New Member
Connor's article is very good. Yes the supporters should be involved as should staff & local community, but i am afraid no matter what is proposed or agreed there will be many who will disagree for whatever reason.
Maybe the only way forward for the owners suggest any upgrades etc and then liaise / involve / ask for idea's etc etc, after taking all information on board go away and digest all this information, then come up with a plan which is put to all at the club, supporters & local community. Basically we have listened and understand the points raised by everyone and as owners / management this is what we are going to do.

Sorry to say this but basically that is what management is about, listen & discuss options, then make a plan and do it.
 
F

Fen Canary

Active Member
The obvious one is capacity, we’ve just about sold out every game since Worthy although I know that doesn’t come cheap. I can’t imagine retrofitting the other stands just to marginally improve the facilities will do too much to be honest
 
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
The obvious one is capacity, we’ve just about sold out every game since Worthy although I know that doesn’t come cheap. I can’t imagine retrofitting the other stands just to marginally improve the facilities will do too much to be honest
Always a toughie that, and there always seems to be a few thousand seats empty most matchdays now. I think the capacity is about where it needs to be with us in this division, but reckon we could do 35k if we were in the Prem. They should have put another corner infill in, instead of building that hotel, but I guess the deal was sweeter. And actually corner infills are terrible value for money anyway.

I think it would be too much financial outlay just now, but it does need addressed, sooner or later, as others have said the City stand and the River end really are showing their age. The only real viable option is another tier on the City stand. But can you imagine the grumbling? :p
 
K

king harr

Member
Always a toughie that, and there always seems to be a few thousand seats empty most matchdays now. I think the capacity is about where it needs to be with us in this division, but reckon we could do 35k if we were in the Prem. They should have put another corner infill in, instead of building that hotel, but I guess the deal was sweeter. And actually corner infills are terrible value for money anyway.

I think it would be too much financial outlay just now, but it does need addressed, sooner or later, as others have said the City stand and the River end really are showing their age. The only real viable option is another tier on the City stand. But can you imagine the grumbling? :p
Like you say they should have put a corner infill instead of the hotel ,I always believe we should have sold max Aaron's when his value was high during COVID and used the money to put another tier on city stand during covid,no fans to worry about it makes perfect sense !
 
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
Like you say they should have put a corner infill instead of the hotel ,I always believe we should have sold max Aaron's when his value was high during COVID and used the money to put another tier on city stand during covid,no fans to worry about it makes perfect sense !
I have seen this analysed and discussed to death elsewhere. And I can't remember the specific ins and outs but I think I remember a price of 30 million to put another tier on? Then there is the lost revenue while you displace people. And to make it work you have to put a bum on that new seat, every single game.

Which it is why I don't think it will ever happen until we have been in the Prem for a few seasons.
 
Danbury Yellow

Danbury Yellow

New Member
I would love to see Carrow Road have a sensible and strategically sequenced plan around upgrades and stadium capacity. I personally think we are falling way behind our competitors on this front. Our neighbours down the road have a very clear plan to get the ground to 40,000 - I’ll whisper it, but I’ve seen the strategy and the proposal, and acknowledge they currently have the cash to do so. A relegation and prolonged championship say would curtail this no doubt.

Through my job, I work consultant side on huge construction schemes, and I’ve attempted to engage with the club (via the company I work for) to help them as the previously advised plan by them landed poorly as it was all structured in completely the wrong sequence, although for a reason. Thus far no reply.

They are (well were) working with an architect firm I know quite well, KSS, these guys have done a number of major ground improvements up and down the uk. And having been in a meeting with them somewhat recently, I’m afraid its viability stopping anything happening. The breaks were applied.

And this is why the ground announcements, now put on hold, included refurbishments of existing fabric only, not the expansion I think many would see as a sensible and logical next step considering how critical turnover is for the operating football model and relocating fans to accommodate corporate seats - love it or hate it, this is all part of major sporting income. Basically a significantly smaller outlay.

But far for beating the club with a stick, they are not alone. The current construction costs are screwed generally and with huge complexities in building legislation, that I won’t bore you with, are stopping projects up and down the land currently. The £30m advice to say stick around 7000 seats is miles off the mark - you can double that.

So after a much longer post than I thought!!! Don’t expect anything too soon on this front, unless NH decide to speculate a developers mind set and increase the value of the club via bricks and mortar.
 
Monty13

Monty13

Active Member
Connor's article is very good. Yes the supporters should be involved as should staff & local community, but i am afraid no matter what is proposed or agreed there will be many who will disagree for whatever reason.
Maybe the only way forward for the owners suggest any upgrades etc and then liaise / involve / ask for idea's etc etc, after taking all information on board go away and digest all this information, then come up with a plan which is put to all at the club, supporters & local community. Basically we have listened and understand the points raised by everyone and as owners / management this is what we are going to do.

Sorry to say this but basically that is what management is about, listen & discuss options, then make a plan and do it.
Change management is one of the hardest things to do because most people do not like change.

Ultimately do it transparently, fairly and with clear communication is the best you can do.

You’ll never get everyone onboard during change.
 
J

Jimmy Bone Superstar

New Member
A full stadium is what helps our team the most and creates that special Norwich atmosphere. Look at the number of times this season we have played in stadiums with rows of empty seats and our own supporters have been the most vociferous. Contrary to popular belief size is not everything….
 
M

muntyNCFC

New Member
I don't think we need a bigger stadium. This season and last season most home games there are plenty of empty seats, as a result of being in the Championship for 5 years and geographically just not having a large population to pull from. I just don't think the value of retrofitting a few thousand seats to Carrow Rd is there. A few successive years in the Prem and I could see a new stadium being built, around 30-35k seats and modern facilities, out near the Broadland business park.
 
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
I don't think we need a bigger stadium. This season and last season most home games there are plenty of empty seats, as a result of being in the Championship for 5 years and geographically just not having a large population to pull from. I just don't think the value of retrofitting a few thousand seats to Carrow Rd is there. A few successive years in the Prem and I could see a new stadium being built, around 30-35k seats and modern facilities, out near the Broadland business park.
A concept I have seen mentioned a few times, and there are pros and cons. The guy above @Danbury Yellow seemed quite knowledgeable, would selling the land at Carrow road and building a whole new stadium elsewhere be a cheaper option?

I am against the plan for purely personal reasons, I live in NR1 and it is a ten minute walk to games!
 
Kevin the Cat

Kevin the Cat

New Member
Like you say they should have put a corner infill instead of the hotel

That could still be done if the club were able to buy the hotel and adapt it to close in that corner. Would add a few hundred seats. Wouldn't displace any fans either.
 
Danbury Yellow

Danbury Yellow

New Member
A concept I have seen mentioned a few times, and there are pros and cons. The guy above @Danbury Yellow seemed quite knowledgeable, would selling the land at Carrow road and building a whole new stadium elsewhere be a cheaper option?

I am against the plan for purely personal reasons, I live in NR1 and it is a ten minute walk to games!
I’m running the numbers for a North East club, and a new build is eye watering for them. Expansion of their large home ground is very limited due to the surroundings for the size of ground they desire. But they have the cash and therefore to keep themselves in line with what they perceive to be a club challenging in England and Europe, it all makes sense.

We also ran the numbers for Chelsea a few years ago, over £1b, that was going ahead until an additional £100m came out to build a tunnel over a railway line - tricky chat that one !!

For us, just in a small sample of us, you can see there is debate on should we have a stadium of 34000 or leave it alone. And if we picked that as the capacity number then staying at Carrow Road makes perfect sense, as two thirds of the ground works already, with some refurbishments / modernisation, we only need to sort capacity of the city stand and I’d suggest this could well be the capacity limit based on pure space required to build over Carrow Road.

My personal view is we should absolutely increase capacity. Norfolk and Norwich has a huge pull for potential fans, build it and they will come - and then guess what, we might get ourselves back in the big time and then it was well worth it. Got to speculate in my view.

NH have past form. You should look at what they did with the Brewers home, very impressive indeed and it gives me hope, but the biggest problem is a football ground is only used min 23 times a season plus what ever cup runs we get, unlike baseball where they play at home almost constantly! Revenue v construction cost v finance loan needs to make sense for a club our size. And no matter how you crunch the numbers, they will never stack - unless you go back to the premise, it’s a development to increase the value of the assets of the club, and that’s my hope, they see the development side rather than an initial short term business model - think the north east club, the numbers don’t work medium term unless they sell the club one day.

Fast forward to a mad idea that in 15 years we have become a mid table prem team and the desire is to get the ground up to say 40,000 - the south stand gets the additional tier, we have the space to do that.

So staying at our home strategically works in the medium and long term I think.
 
alex_ncfc

alex_ncfc

New Member
I'd hate to move away from Carrow Road as some have suggested, that's our home.

But maybe a substantial gradual rebuild could take place in future years. The two end stands are looking very tired, and less said about the City Stand the better.
 

Sit with the City fans who turn up

Free to join, free to read. Introduce yourself, pick a player thread, and get stuck into the next match thread.

Create a free account
Top