Youth contracts / comings and goings.

Din

Din

Well-Known Member
I do think Jacob is the better play, however I also believe that if he was to leave that Josh could easily step up and take his place. I have said before I believe that technically Josh has a slight edge, however Jacob is a lot better at utilising his pace and beating his man. Jacob happened to be the one who Alex Neil gave a chance, and fair play to him because he took that chance, but once Neil left Irvine often seemed to prefer Josh who would usually always do a good job. Wouldn't sell for less than £15m, and even then in today's market I'd probably try and squeeze a little bit more out of Newcastle. I would rather he didn't leave though.
 
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
Rumour is that Newcastle have bid up to 12.5 million for Murphy. Looks like we were right to play hardball!
 
Fenway Frank

Fenway Frank

Well-Known Member
Mashiter saying it could turn out to be our most expensive sale when the extras all kick in 
 
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
Mashiter saying it could turn out to be our most expensive sale when the extras all kick in 
I should hope so seeing as it stands at 13 million for Brady! 

We better have some decent sell ons in there!
 
Scott

Scott

Active Member
Every player has a price, sad to see Jacob go but at least we get to keep the good one ;)
 
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
Crazy money.
Yes and no.

Yes he has had one good season, and not even in the Premiership, but if you look at some of the daft transfers recently, its probably about right. I do hope we have decent sell on clauses though, just in case he continues to improve. Strange to think that this time last season he was hardly even being talked about. And any talk was that his brother was better than him.

I think the timing of this, and the price are both about right.
 
G

GJP

Well-Known Member
Yes and no.

Yes he has had one good season, and not even in the Premiership, but if you look at some of the daft transfers recently, its probably about right. I do hope we have decent sell on clauses though, just in case he continues to improve. Strange to think that this time last season he was hardly even being talked about. And any talk was that his brother was better than him.

I think the timing of this, and the price are both about right.
Yeah it's the sort of going rate. Which is crazy.

If we had the money would I want us to spend it on Jacob? Probably not.
 
morty

morty

Moderator
Staff member
Yeah it's the sort of going rate. Which is crazy.

If we had the money would I want us to spend it on Jacob? Probably not.
Remember this from last summer?

:D

Untitled.jpg
 
G

GJP

Well-Known Member
Remember this from last summer?

:D

Lolz.

Be interesting to see how he does. He's got a bit of pace and he's got a goal in him. But his movement isn't great and neither is his link up play. Hard to tell how much that can improve at this stage of his career.
 
hogesar

hogesar

Well-Known Member
Disappointed to lose him - could look like a great price if he doesn't kick off from here but in a flawed tactical system and a struggling team away from home in his first ever season  at Championship level his returns were very good for a winger. If he does kick on and do well it'll look like a snip for a young English winger.
 
The Fish

The Fish

New Member
Newcastle fan here. Pretty happy with a young promising wide player who looks like he's got good technique, a decent finish and plenty of movement. Doesn't hurt that there's been a picture of him and his brother in a Newcastle shirt (so he's totally a Newcastle fan, right?... right? Ah come on guys) I'm sure Ashley will be happy with a player with resale value.

Transfer fee aside (this market is mental) do you think he's a good signing for a side that'll likely be at the wrong end of the Premier League table for much of the season? A side that plays pragmatic, counter attack football.
 
G

GJP

Well-Known Member
I'd rather have Jacob than Brady. But I'd rather have Redderz than Jacob.
 

Sit with the City fans who turn up

Free to join, free to read. Introduce yourself, pick a player thread, and get stuck into the next match thread.

Create a free account
Top